Amee Lê
When the weather finally picked up for what’s considered a cool summer in Berlin, Lars von Trier came to Babylon, the city’s festival theater, to kick off a retrospective on his works and to hopefully find some redemption for his previous public appearance that had arguably cost the Danish director the 2011 Palme d’Or while having earned him the title ‘persona non grata’ first ever to be declared at the Cannes. I sacrificed the rare sunny afternoon toward the end of my internship in Berlin to line up in a packed lobby, with decreasing oxygen and increasing excitement, during the one hour leading up to the Q&A event.
Lars von Trier is notorious for his lack of mercy for the audience. Found in his films are some of the most psychologically difficult, if not disturbing, stories as well as visual images employed to tell them, habitually in a fairytale manner. Trier’s masterful use of the Brechtian distancing effect leaves no one innocent as watching a Trier film often forces one to face one’s own senses of greed, guilt, and despair. In Dogvile (2003), the first in Trier’s projected USA – Land of Opportunities trilogy (including Manderlay (2005) and to-be-completed Washington), during almost three hours of emotional and physical torture scenes, the audience will slowly be turned from a justified sympathizer to a bewildered accomplice in a horrid crime of revenge by the central character Grace. While asked about Dogville as a critique of a country he never set foot on, Trier explained that he had always been brought up to be against the US and the Vietnam War, and more blatantly, to feel nauseated every time America was mentioned as a great nation.
In 1995, inspired by the French New Wave of the 60s, Lars von Trier co-founded Dogme 95 with Thomas Vinterberg. The avant-garde movement was intended to render filmmaking more accessible by declaring manifestos that required on-location shooting with hand-held cameras, minimum to no editing and special effects, as well as non-credited directors. The movement produced many critically acclaimed films such as The Celebration (Dogme #1), The Idiots (Dogme #2), Julien Donkey-Boy (Dogme #6), and Kira’s Reason: A Love Story (Dogme #21). Trier, like other Dogme directors, admitted to having cheated on the principles of Dogme and is no longer making strictly Dogme films. When German newspaper Die Welt’s film editor Hanns-Georg Rodek confronted Trier about what the latter was thinking when he wrote in one of his manifestos that there should be more heterosexual films of, by, and for men, Trier dodged the issue by saying that manifestos were written just to be thrown away and giving nods to great ‘heterosexual films’ made by homosexual directors such as Fassbinder and Pasolini.
The topics of Trier as a provocateur and the recent Cannes incident unavoidably dominated the Q&A. The prologue of the auteur’s most controversial film yet Antichrist (2009) is perhaps one of the most poetic and perturbing pieces of hard-core porn that has ever graced the movie screen. It also validates Trier’s assertion that children are only props in his films. The film deals with Trier’s defined three stages of guilt – pain, grief, and despair. Once again, in response to the German film critic about provocation as an art form, Trier emphasized the importance of being rebellious. Having already confessed to being someone who was against everything, Trier argued that provocation while making people angry also made them think and reconsider things; and being provocative was about having an opinion and taking part in life. He admitted however that there was also bad provocation. This led back to what had happened at Cannes and before Cannes, at Trier’s mother’s deathbed. Trier had only learned about who his real father was shortly before his mother passed away. He had believed during most of his life that he was Jewish, only to find out that he was of German descent. This provided the pretext for the awful joke Trier made at Cannes this year that he had always thought he was a Jew but it turned out that he was a Nazi. Trier then dug himself deeper into the grave by commenting that he sympathized with Hitler. For this, Trier is now banned from Cannes. A perhaps intentionally unwise member from the Q&A audience asked Trier to recontextualize the N-word now that he was in Germany, which received a great boo from everyone else. Trier redeemed himself with the Berlin audience by acknowledging his foolishness (“…but I’m only a human,” he added), claiming that we were all a bit Nazis, and stressing the importance of not making a taboo out of the subject. The speech’s resonance with the audience was confirmed by a hearty round of applause.
Besides the reputation as a sadist for placing exceeding demands on people working on his films, Lars von Trier is also accused of being a misogynist for having often made martyrs out of his female protagonists. Ironically, under his direction, there have been three Best Actress wins at the Cannes including Dancer in the Dark’s Bjork, Antichrist’s Charlotte Gainsbourg, and even Melancholia’s Kirsten Dunst despite the aforementioned unfortunate event at the film’s press conference. Melancholia (2011) too contains a visually breathtaking prologue perfectly set to the music of Wagner’s Tristan and Isolde’s prelude. The title, also the name of a blue planet in the film, is not only an obvious reference to depression, with which Trier himself is not unfamiliar, but an encompassing emblem for a sense of despair in us all as well. The sickening dance of Death between the planets Earth and Melancholia is sped up in the film by the human tragicomedies of empty rituals (in this case, the most expensive wedding a bride can have) and failed relationships (Trier seems to blame the parents for this one – we either inherit or are made messed up by our parents). The disheartening theme can be forgiven, however, for the visual decadence of stunning imagery created by either quoting or ‘paraphrasing’ the many classical paintings including Pieter Brueghel’s The Hunters in the Snow (1565), Caspar David Friedrich’s Wanderer above the Sea of Fog (1818), John Everett Millais’s Ophelia (1852), and Edvard Munch’s The Dance of Life (1899). The director of Babylon Timothy Grossmann awkwardly commented on Melancholia that he never knew dying could be so pretty. For me personally and with all of the Trier films I have seen, there is always a Nietzschean sense of liberation in Trier’s acceptance of fallible humanity.
Commenting on his next film Nymphomaniac, Trier perfected his role as the entertainer of the day by stating that the film was made out of his deep respect for female sexuality but “I’m just saying it because you won’t see it in the film.” Human, all too human!
All the film titles mentioned in this article, except for Melancholia, which will premiere in Toronto at the Toronto International Film Festival on Sept. 17, 2011, can be found at the Sound and Moving Image Library, Scott Library.